Over three months had passed since Oceanic Flight 815 had crashed on an unknown island, and for the first time the survivors had made contact. Rescue was on its way... so why the uncertainty? A web of lies still bound them all, making it impossible to tell the truth from the falsities, and hope from hopelessness. The people from the Freighter were not who they claimed to be, so what else were they lying about? As dangerous as the Island was... would it be more dangerous to leave? Desmond had reported it wasn’t Penny’s boat, so who was it, and why would they lie? What exactly did they have on their minds that they couldn’t share with the Survivors of Flight 815?

Jack Sheppard believes that their salvation has come and is willing to do anything to go home. He’s ready and willing to risk the chance that they are bad people. He’s confident they’re good, and at this point who is willing to hold him back. John Locke believes that the Island is their salvation, and is willing to do more than anything to stay. He claims these people are the bad people, and believes what Ben is saying, while he won’t stop Jack, he will lead his followers to safety or their ultimate demise? Who is right? Who is wrong?

Who will you side with?